Yoga and Eating Disorders – Recovery from the Anti-Identity

Posted by Karen on June 6, 2009 | 6 Comments

In grade nine my class went on a week-long retreat to a camp near Vancouver. One night, our teachers had us participate in a personality assessment. It was presented to us as a fun activity of self discovery, and I honestly believe they naively meant it as nothing more than that.

Each of us filled out the multiple choice questionnaire. After tallying our results we were physically separated in four quadrants representing combinations of introverted vs. extroverted and global vs. analytical traits. In our segregated groups we stared or shouted at each other (this varied considerably between the introverted and extroverted groups) and studied our newly branded identity.

personal-idFor the remainder of the trip, the teachers were left to clean up the carnage of a hormone induced group emotional breakdown. Although this was my first memorable lesson in the process of self-identification, the pressure to define our individuality began sooner than grade nine, and can persist long after our teenage years.

Many metaphors have beautifully described humanity’s quest for personal identification. In Pink Floyd’s concept album “The Wall”, the antihero struggles with the barricade separating his shriveling inner self and the outside world. The bricks were laid by himself and others, forming a superficial but effective external identity – an activity condoned to a less dramatic degree in most of our lives.

But there is a concept that I feel is under-represented. Every posture has a counterpose, and personal identity is no exception. I’ll call it the anti-identity.

Eating Disorders and Anti-Identity

I believe that individuals suffering from eating disorders are attempting to dissolve any visceral and psychological sense of identity that society pressures them to have. Others may argue anorexia, bulimia and other disorders are just another external identity statement – but I believe this condition is defined not by what you are, but by what you are not.

I am not perfect. I am not logical. I am not smart. I am not beautiful. I am not strong. I am not what you think. I am not here. In the end, I am really not here.

The further the condition progresses, the closer to those ends the person suffering becomes. The side-effect is a feeling of success, which feeds the anti-identity and perpetuates the illness.

Eating disorders have the highest mortality rate of any mental illness. It’s potent stuff, and it’s no surprise to me that the incidence of eating disorders is escalating, especially in individual-centric cultures. It’s not a pressure to be thin, but a pressure to harden ourselves against malleability; to build a external manifestation of who we are.

Yoga and Eating Disorders

When an individual is recovering from an eating disorder, one of the most terrifying questions is “When I recover, who will I be?”. The misunderstanding is that the fear is not rooted in weight-gain itself; weight brings emotions, laughter and energy. The apprehension results from the perceived pressure to form an identity, and have other people assess and judge that identity.

For those suffering with eating disorders, the need to find balance is imperative, it’s a matter of survival. Yoga has a lot to say about the Self, and many tools to help a person achieve balance. I was delighted to read that in Vancouver, the leading eating disorder treatment program now incorporates yoga into their recovery program.

Yoga can aid in eating disorder recovery on a number of levels. Benefits like increased presence of body and mind, lowered stress and increased strength are well known. But ultimately, yoga is a powerful recovery tool because it trains a person to lighten their grip of the importance of their “lower self”. By this I mean the formation of traits, physical and psychological, that we internalize and project: the external testimony of who we are.

Between identity and anti-identity, there lies a balance that is rooted in impermanence. We are different every day, and it’s simply not important to waste energy forming or dissolving an external identity. Osho said many beautiful things, and one sticks in my head right now

At the end only that remains which you had brought in the beginning.

It’s been a long journey, and I am only starting to internalize this idea. Now I wake with it. I sit with it on my yoga mat. And I fall asleep with it when my consciousness dissolves into the inky sky blistering with pure starlight.

  1. Tianne replied on June 7, 2009

    I love that quote from Osho. You write beautifully and I’m adding your blog to my faves :)

  2. Kate replied on June 8, 2009

    Beautifully written Karen!

    Good food for thought…

    I am finding so many memories tied into foods that I am re-sampling back here in New Zealand. It’s an interesting journey discovering different sights and smells that I didn’t realise were part of my “identity”.

    Did you enjoy the kayaking on the weekend?

    Kate

  3. Sally replied on June 8, 2009

    Hi Karen:

    This post brought up many interesting memories of the angst and struggles to find self and a way to fit in with peers and society. I think I have always felt (and enjoyed) some degree of being an outcast / nonconformer…

    Your comments on “defined not by what you are, but by what you are not” are very thought provoking.

    Really enjoying your writing and blog.

    Sally

  4. Gaby replied on August 10, 2009

    Hi Karen,
    I just found your blog today while browsing yoga blogs and….I don’t know that I’ve ever been so moved by a blog post. This was so well written and seriously, each and every word describes the very essence of an eating disorder- something so impossible to understand to those who have not lived it.
    I found it hard to hold back tears because everything you’ve said is ME. I’d be curious to know where your first quote is from because I wrote a poem back when I was 16 that says that exact same thing almost word for word. I should send it to you because it’s eerie! And that was years before my struggles with an eating disorder. But the more research I’ve done on the subject, the more I see so clearly now that it could have been predicted from miles away. My thoughts, my environment, my personality and the way I’ve always dealt with stress.
    I’ve been better for over a year and a half now and have to say that yoga has been vital to recovering. It has centered me, allowed me to respect my body for its strength and beauty, and it reminds me that it needs to be treated well. I still deal with anxiety and stress like anyone else, but yoga always helps, and I now try to practice at least 2 or 3 times a week. I can see a noticeable difference in how I feel emotionally and physically when I stick to a regular yoga routine.
    I’ve sort of rambled on but thank you so much for writing this and you’re getting added to my blogroll favorites!

    - Gaby

    • Karen replied to Gaby on August 10, 2009

      Hi Gaby – thanks for your sincere comment. It’s come to me at a time where I really needed an positive vibe so thanks for taking the time to share! (everyone has these days)

      That first quote was mine – I wrote it recently, reflecting on my headspace when I was at my worst. I’d love to read your poem if you feeling like sending that my way. My email is mail at karen-mackenzie.com.

      I’ve felt very much the same about yoga – not that it would work for everyone but I certainly have found that it’s calmed me and gradually is helping me turn my attention to what’s really important – inner peace so I can live to the fullest and share this with people I love. Keep working on recovery – I understand how long and hard that path is.

      Karen

  5. Namaste Vancouver (Yoga Directory) replied on November 6, 2009

    Great article Karen! Very well written.

    Great that Yoga is bringing inner peace to you which is the most important thing.

    Thanks for sharing! We invite you to join Vancouver’s Yoga Community http://yogacommunityvancouver.ning.com/ and share your love of Yoga with all.

    Namaste!

Leave a Comment

Space and Time

  • Categories